Home / World / California the Next South Carolina with Mudslide Closing Highway 5

California the Next South Carolina with Mudslide Closing Highway 5

By William Church

Heavy rain and hail near Ft. Tejon California triggered a massive mudslide that closed Interstate 5 a major North-South highway about 30 miles from Los Angeles this afternoon.  Homes were knocked off their foundations and tractor trailers were swept away.

Only two weeks after extreme weather crippled  South Carolina it is now California’s turn for extreme weather as it goes into the first round of El Nino weather arriving in November. If South Carolina was a recipe for disaster with a combination of vulnerable dams and extreme weather, then California may double down on the same recipe with extra ingredients that could exponentially bring California to its knees.  California potentially has the  the perfect mix for this coming disaster that today’s massive mudslide could just be the beginning.

California the Next South Carolina with Mudslide closing Highway 5

Bill Patzert of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory calls it the Godzilla El Niño and most climatologists agree there is a 95 percent chance it will be an above average event. Normal El Ninos could bring double the amount of rain in a normal season. Unlike South Carolina, it will not be concentrated in a week or a few days.  It will be a season long event that will continually undermine California’s infrastructure.  South Carolina had 10 percent of its dams listed as a high danger of collapse and a major flood occurred when only 20 of them failed. California has 1594 dams and over 50 percent (824) are listed as a high risk of collapse, according to the US Army Corp of Engineers.

The good news and bad news is that California has been in a multi-year drought.  Most of the lakes, reservoirs and farm holding ponds are significantly below capacity. Folsom Reservoir sits at a historic low of 171,428 acre feet of water, which is a record low.   Most of the 824 high risk dams, like South Carolina, are private, earthen dams that are subject to erosion at the base and not just collapsing from over capacity.  Many times the rating of high risk comes from structural issues not capacity issues.

According to the American Society of Civil Engineers, California’s private dams have been neglected for years and are old. The US Army Corp of Engineers notes that 17 percent (281) of all dams are over 100 years old. Including those 281 dams, a total of 533 dams are 75 years old. In all, 1160 or 72 percent of California’s dams are 50 years old and this explains the high percentage of structurally deficient dams.

Adding to the drought’s bad news, California has suffered massive forest fires–over 8.2 million acres burned, according to the National Interagency Fire Center-in both the north and south of the state in 2015.  To put this in perspective California had 33 million acres prior to 2015 so this means that California lost 25 percent of its ground cover in one year.  This significant loss will accelerate the flow of water and increase its force when it hits a standing object like a bridge or dam. If that object is already a structurally deficient dam then the results are predictable.

Another problem is that California is sinking.  California’s Department of Water Resources reported that drought related over pumping of groundwater by farmers has caused water levels to drop by some 100 feet resulting in ground sinkage by as much as 13 inches in the city of Corcoran and some parts of the California Aqueduct has sunk as much as 8 inches. Obviously, this calls into question any rigid structure like dams, bridges, or highways which can be undermined by the ground loss.

This risk extends to California’s critical levee system. The American Society of Civil Engineers rated California’s levees as a D in 2012, which is actually better than the F they received in 2010.  The most significant levee protects the Sacramento Delta from the seawater of the San Francisco Bay. It is where freshwater meets sea water.

The Sacramento Delta receives runoff from 40 percent of California land and about 50 percent of California stream flow.  It is a major source of fresh water with 7.5 million acre feet per year pumped out which means about two-thirds of Californians receive some portion of their water from the Delta, according to the US Geological Survey.  

The Delta’s levees are being hit by a double whammy.  First, the land is sinking from the collapse of the aquifer and other reasons. Second, local news sources report that the San Joaquin River levee has sunk more than six feet, which makes them vulnerable to being overtopped by a weather surge. But the levees may collapse regardless.  

Three scientists (Farshid Vahedifard, Amir Aghakouchak, and Joe Robinson) report that California’s levees are decomposing rapidly because of the drought because they sit on peat which is common in the Delta. The drought has caused something called SOC (Soil Organic Carbon) to rapidly decompose.  Matter of fact, it is believed that 75 percent of land subsidence is accredited to SOC.

This leaves a vulnerable Delta to levee collapse and a rush of seawater into California’s freshwater supply.

Land_Subsidence_in_the_Delta_Eric_Chase_1995
Graphic: California Department of Water Resources (1995)

It is difficult to determine the exact effect heavy and prolonged El Nino rains will have on the already weakened levees.  The one important factor that is still unknown is the amount of El Nino driven rain and the frequency. The largest El Nino to hit California to date was in the 1997-1998 season.  The San Francisco Bay Area, where the Sacramento Delta levees are located, received double its normal rain at 47 inches.  Los Angeles went from a normal or average rainfall of 3.5 inches for the season to 13.68 inches.  If this El Nino, as predicted, is larger than the El Nino of 1997-1998 the destruction in California could be significant.

sfo_lanina
Graphic: Department of Geosciences, San Francisco State University
lax_lanina
Graphic: Department of Geosciences, San Francisco State University

The El Nino of 1997-1998 was not preceded by a fire season where California lost 25 percent of rain slowing forests, nor did California go into that season with an Aqueduct that had sunk 8 inches in some locations nor levees that had sunk over six foot. The lack of ground cover will also make many urban areas around Los Angeles and Sacramento vulnerable to massive mud slides like the one today at Ft. Tejon.

This is the second extreme weather event for California this year. Earlier this year in July  rain fell at the rate of one inch per hour for a sustained period.  The Tex Wash Bridge in Desert Center was swept away by a tidal wave of water that was 15 feet above the normal level for the wash. Floods and mudslides were triggered all over the area.

Today’s massive mudslide might be a sign a very difficult rainy season for California.

 

About William Church

Check Also

Boston mobster's longtime love pleads guilty to contempt

Boston mobster’s longtime love pleads guilty to contempt

BOSTON –  The woman who spent 16 years on the run with Boston mobster James …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *